DHCR Clarifies That Rent Concessions Are Not Preferential Rents

Over the past several years a slew of tenant-initiated litigation has commenced involving rent stabilized apartments where the landlord provided tenants with rent concessions for specific months of a lease. Historically, such rent concessions were considered by DHCR to be distinct from preferential rents, i.e., rents below the legal regulated rent, where the concession did not exceed three months and the tenant paid the full monthly rent for the duration of the lease term. The distinction was set forth in DHCR Fact Sheet No. 40, as well as administrative orders.

On June 14, 2019, the Legislature passed and Governor Cuomo signed into law the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, which required landlords who were charging an amount that was less than the legal regulated rent for a stabilized apartment, e.g., a preferential rent, to continue providing the lower rent on any renewal, increased only by a “guideline” adjustment or a rent increase approved by DHCR—this requirement applied to any lease in effect on and after June 14, 2019. Several months after the HSTPA was enacted, the example clearly distinguishing “rent concessions” from “preferential rents” was removed from Fact Sheet 40 without explanation. In the following years, as litigation ensued to determine whether rent concessions were, in fact, preferential rents that must continue to be offered on renewal, the change to Fact Sheet 40 came to play an outsized role in the courts’ analysis. Most recently, several appellate decisions have held that the change to Fact Sheet 40 in 2019 represented a “change of guidance” with respect to “post-HSTPA rent concessions.” The appellate courts concession (no pun intended) that post-HSTPA rent concessions should be treated as preferential rents has created an uncomfortable environment for any landlord who relied on and complied with Fact Sheet 40, only to be informed years later that rent concessions that the owner offered may be binding on renewal leases, and may give reason for a tenant to demand a lower rent and refund over “overcharges.”

This confusion appears to have been addressed today by DHCR with the issuance of an updated Fact Sheet 40. In relevant part, the version published today states that “DHCR continues to recognize that there are distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents, and DHCR’s 2019 modification of Fact Sheet #40 was not intended to indicate the contrary.” There is certain to be more litigation on the issue of rent concessions. However, the Agency’s issuance of this clarifying language will hopefully lay to rest claims that the simple removal of an example six years ago created a sea change in policy established over the preceding twenty years.

For questions about the clarification or its application to your properties, contact Vladimir Favilukis or James Marino, Partners in our Rent Regulation & Administrative Law Practice and Co-Chairs of KMWB’s DHCR Group.

Media Contacts:

Briana Spariosu
Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens, LLP
(212) 869-5030
bspariosu@kuckermarino.com